---
title: "The Rise of Global OCIO Services and the Implications"
document_role: "발간물 글"
language: "en"
published: "2016-08-02"
authors:
  - "Kim, Jaechil"
description: "Institutional investors in the US and Europe tend to outsource investment management to external managers, i.e., outsourced chief investment officers (OCIOs) on a full or partial discretionary basis."
canonical_url: "https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pubend_view?syear=2016&zcd=002001002&zno=1254&cno=4226"
publication: "Capital Market Opinion(August 02, 2016)"
---

# The Rise of Global OCIO Services and the Implications

[뷰어](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/flexer/view?fid=20646&fgu=002001&fty=004003)
[원글](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pubend_view?syear=2016&zcd=002001002&zno=1254&cno=4226)
## Page 1

Capital Market Opinion




     The Rise of Global OCIO Services and the Implications

                                                                                                                  Kim, Jaechil



               Institutional investors in the US and Europe tend to outsource investment
           management to external managers, i.e., outsourced chief investment
           officers (OCIOs) on a full or partial discretionary basis. Growth in the global
           OCIO market stems from the move of institutional investors seeking more
           efficient asset management amid the low interest rate and low investment
           returns. OCIO services’ expansion in the post-crisis era implies that asset
           management companies are jumping in value-added, comprehensive
           investment management services. Although some Korean public funds
           adopt the “lead manager system” akin to OCIOs, it is highly likely for private
           pensions to become a core client pool in the OCIO market going forward.
           Korean asset management companies seeking to create value by playing
           a key role in domestic and overseas OCIO markets should build their
           capabilities as an OCIO. Toward that end, they are required to carry out bold
           investments in necessary areas such as human resources.



        The rise of the outsourced chief investment officers (OCIO) model is one of the dominant
     trends in the global asset management market. An OCIO refers to an external service provider
     who is hired to provide full or partial discretionary investment management services for large-
     scale investors such as institutional investors or high-net-worth individuals. Such services are
     mostly provided by asset management companies, professional investment consultants, and
     pension actuaries, etc. Their major work scope differs depending on the services delegated,
     but includes almost all tasks related to investment management. In most cases, OCIO providers


       All opinions expressed in this paper represent the author’s personal views and thus should not be interpreted as Korea Capital
       Market Institute’s official position.
       Ph.D., Senior Research Fellow, Fund & Pension Department, Tel: 82-2-3771-0663, E-mail: jckim@kcmi.re.kr




1   August 02, 2016

## Page 2

Capital Market Opinion



carry out tactical asset allocation, hire external investment managers, internally manage the
outsourced assets, and measure performance. But they are at times directly or indirectly
involved in more important tasks, e.g., asset-liability management, strategic asset allocation, and
the investment policy statement (IPS).
    A similar business model has just started in Korea. Since the investment pool for public
funds by the Ministry of Strategy and Finance adopted the “lead manager system” akin to OCIO
services in 2001, this has expanded to other funds such as the Housing and Urban Development
Fund by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transportation; the Employment Insurance
Fund and Workers’ Compensation Insurance by the Ministry of Employment and Labor; and
the investment pool for private pension funds by Korea Securities Finance Corp. (KSFC). But
the lack of experience and service diversity of service providers and excessively low fees make
OCIO services hardly viable as a revenue model.1) This article touches upon the current state of
the global OCIO market, the background behind the market’s growth, and the implications of
such growth for asset management companies. Then, I look at Korea’s OCIO market to assess
the potential and to discuss future directions in which Korean asset managers should head for
enhancing their role as an OCIO.


    Current state of the global OCIO market
    According to the data from Pension & Investments (P&I, 2015), the aggregate amount of
assets managed worldwide for institutional investors amounted to approximately $1.4 trillion
(KRW 1,550 trillion) as of March 2015, a 16% increase from the same period of the previous
year.2) Russell Investments, an investment consulting firm, was the largest OCIO provider with
$117.3 billion in outsourced assets under management. Among the top 10 OCIO providers,
there were six asset management companies and four investment consulting firms including
Russell Investments. Investment consulting firms that have proliferated since the enactment of
the Employee Retirement Income Security Act governing the US corporate pension system are
known to recruit a wide variety of corporate pension experts including investment managers.
Banks, trust companies, and investment banks also provide OCIO services.



1) Refer to Public Funds’ Lead Manager System: Meaning and Implications (Chaewoo Nam, 2015, KCMI Capital Market Opinion).
2) Refer to the Special Report: Investment Outsourcing (P&I, 2015).




                                                                                                                            2

## Page 3

Capital Market Opinion



         A survey released by investment data provider Asset International (AI, 2016) shows a more
     detailed picture on who clients and service providers are in the OCIO market.3) Differentiated
     from P&I statistics, AI data include full discretion services only. As of the end of 2015, corporate
     pensions were the largest client pool managing 52.4% of outsourced assets in aggregate.
     Endowments/foundations and public/government pensions accounted for the second largest
     proportion. Also, insurance companies were one of OCIO clients although the size was not large.
         A regional breakdown on the client data that were available from seven players out of top
     10 OCIO providers showed that clients from the US and Canada accounted for 73.1% and
     those from the UK and Europe for 16.1%. Clients from other regions represented a negligible
     percentage. Notably, almost 69% of the clients surveyed was found to have outsourced
     investment management functions for over three years. Give that quite a few of those have used
     outsourcing for over a decade, the contract period between OCIO clients and service providers
     seems not short.
         When it comes to the fees OCIO providers receive in exchange for their services, a total of
     58% of contracts were based on flat fees while performance fees were adopted in only 20% of
     contracts. But contracts based on performance fees have been on the rise every year. Although
     the exact fee level charged by OCIO providers is unknown, the average fee is estimated to range
     from 30bp to 100bp depending on the size of outsourced assets.4)


         Behind the growth of the OCIO market
         The 2016 survey by AI also questioned institutional investors (clients) the reasons for
     outsourcing investment management. Respondents were given seven reasons and asked to rank
     them in order of importance. The followings list the result in descending order according to the
     proportion of respondents citing each of the item as the most critical: Lack of internal resources
     (56%); additional fiduciary oversight, better risk management (38%, each); need to increase
     returns, faster implementation/decisions (31%, each); desire for strategic partnership (18%);
     and cost savings (11%). Such results indicate that investment returns are not necessarily the
     only factor explaining institutional investors’ tendency of outsourcing. Despite the importance
     of converging various tasks (e.g., transparent supervision, faster decision making, and a balance

     3) Refer to the 2016 Outsourced Chief Investment Officers Survey (AI, 2016).
     4) Refer to Considering the OCIO Option: Not an Everyday Decision for Fiduciaries (RV Kuhns & Associates, Inc., 2013).




3   August 02, 2016

## Page 4

Capital Market Opinion



between returns and risk management) for managing ever-growing assets properly, institutional
investors came to realize that they lack internal resources for carrying out all of those tasks.
   Taking into account that view, the rapid expansion of the global OCIO market seems
attributable to the following three aspects. First, it is extremely difficult for institutional investors
to rely entirely on internal resources to boost their asset values amid the prolonged low-
interest-rate and low-return environment. Second, the growing diversity in financial products
and distributors is adding difficulties for institutional investors to choose suitable products and
distributors. Third, what is critical under today’s complex financial market environment is the
duty of fiduciary oversight that can be enhanced only by external experts such as OCIO providers.
   To sum up, the global OCIO market grew behind the firm belief among institutional investors
that OCIOs contribute to stronger asset management governance and consequently enhance
efficiency in asset management.


   Implications of OCIO growth for asset managers
   In the past, asset managers were expected to focus on selecting the most optimal investment
assets at which they have strength. Comprehensive, customized asset management services
such as strategic asset allocation and asset-liability management were regarded outside their
boundary. Rather, asset managers were asked to play a limited role of simply providing fund
products or discretionary investment services based on decisions made at the upper level by
asset owners.
   But more recently, not only institutional investors and high-net-worth individuals, but
also retail investors are keen to go beyond mass products and choose so-called “investment
solutions” reflecting their own investment purposes. Target date funds, asset allocation
funds, and absolute return funds are some of the examples although they are not a perfectly
customized product. Domestic and overseas asset management companies have already
designed and provided partially customized products to the public.
   On top of that, the rapid expansion of the global OCIO market and the increased role
played by asset management companies imply that asset managers have already jumped in
comprehensive investment management services in full throttle. It is noteworthy that the global
OCIO market has been widely recognized as a new, high value-added business, which inevitably
creates severe competition.


                                                                                                            4

## Page 5

Capital Market Opinion



        Potential in Korea’s OCIO market and challenges ahead
        The background that fueled the growth of the global OCIO market can be applicable to Korea.
     Unlike developed countries already in the decumulation phase, Korea’s pension assets can be
     accumulated for a substantially long period going forward. In particular, the size of retirement
     pension assets is projected to increase steeply. The introduction of trust-based retirement
     pensions will see a greater number of retirement pensions achieving economies of scale, e.g.,
     single-employer pensions by large-sized companies. Accordingly, many private pensions will
     emerge as a formidable client base in Korea’s OCIO market where public pension funds are
     currently dominant clients. The case of developed countries demonstrates that university
     endowments and foundations can be prospective clients in this market. Of course, small-scale
     private pension funds can tap into OCIO services via KSFC’s investment pool for private pension
     funds. However, there will be clear demand for enjoying superb services from individual OCIOs.
        The Korean OCIO market emerged based on public funds as a dominant client pool, but
     is currently viewed as a hardly viable revenue model due to the limited service scope and
     excessively low fees. If OCIO providers build up their capabilities to serve for a number of
     retirement pensions or other private pensions, this may help reevaluate, albeit limitedly, the
     optimal fee levels. Because of the low-profit structure of Korean OCIO services, Korean asset
     management companies may seek to expand overseas if they vamp up the efforts for improving
     their OCIO capabilities.
        What is vital is how Korean asset management companies can build their capabilities for
     OCIO services. First and foremost, they need a system through which they can fully understand
     and carry out comprehensive OCIO services. For example, pension funds with a long-term
     liability must carry out strategic asset allocation fully considering the optimal funding level,
     a service currently out of the range of Korean asset management companies. Although this
     is a task mostly implemented by a top decision-making body (an operation committee or a
     board) in overseas cases, it is known that OCIO providers often intervene in the process via
     advisory services, etc. For this, OCIO providers must aggressively recruit professionals needed
     to assess the payout structure for pension beneficiaries as well as the optimal funding level. The
     importance of manpower will grow further as the number of clients receiving OCIO services
     rises. Because every institutional investor differs in nature, OCIOs must fully understand the
     unique nature and reflect that in designing customized services.



5   August 02, 2016

## Page 6

Capital Market Opinion



   Also important is a due diligence system in selecting external managers. In Korea, there are
over 100 asset management companies authorized by law. If overseas players are included,
the due diligence process will get much more complex. Hence, it would be critical to build a
database that includes not only the list of domestic and overseas service providers, but also
the data on their service features. Another area requiring attention is a tool that systematically
compiling data on the whole OCIO service process including risk management, performance
evaluation, reporting, etc.
   In conclusion, capabilities of OCIOs are determined by their ability to provide customized
services suiting individual needs of a wide range of customers. And this requires aggressive
investments in manpower as well as systems. Going forward, asset management companies
seeking to advance into OCIO services in search for a new revenue model must make bold
decisions based on their market insight.




                                                                                                     6

