---
title: "ESG Stock Performance amid Covid-19"
document_role: "발간물 글"
language: "en"
published: "2021-03-09"
authors:
  - "Park, Hyejin"
description: "This article explores the impact of corporate environmental and social (ES) activities on stock returns amid the market crisis triggered by the Covid-19 pandemic."
canonical_url: "https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pub_detail_view?syear=2021&zcd=002001017&zno=1584&cno=5655"
publication: "OPINION(March 09, 2021)"
---

# ESG Stock Performance amid Covid-19

[뷰어](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/flexer/view?fid=24282&fgu=002001&fty=004003)
[원글](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pub_detail_view?syear=2021&zcd=002001017&zno=1584&cno=5655)
## Page 1

OPINION                                                                     Capital Market Focus




                     ESG Stock Performance amid Covid-19
                                                                                                                   Park, Hyejin*



                This article explores the impact of corporate environmental and social (ES)
            activities on stock returns amid the market crisis triggered by the Covid-19
            pandemic. A series of analyses carried out here showed that stocks with higher
            ES scores tend to have a lower price decline. This means that firms with superb
            ES performance could be less susceptible to an unexpected shock such as
            Covid-19. Although the academic circle has yet to reach a consensus on the
            impact of ESG factors on stock performance, the results here show—albeit
            partially—the importance of non-financial factors such as ESG in investment
            decisions.




          The Covid-19 pandemic not only gave the biggest shock to the global economy after the
      global financial crisis, but also triggered investors to question about firm sustainability. In a
      JP Morgan survey targeting 50 global institutional investors, about 55% of the respondents
      expected ESG investing to gain momentum for the next three years in the aftermath
      of Covid-19, while 71% said that Covid-19 could give more limelight to climate change,
      biodiversity, and other sustainability agenda.1) As the stock market plunged with the spread of
      the Covid-19, the global fund market saw a net outflow of $384.7 billion during the first quarter
      of 2020 alone, while ESG funds saw a net inflow of $45.6 billion. This evidences investors still
      paying keen attention on ESG investing.2)
          Against that backdrop, the impact of ESG activities on financial performance during the
      time of crisis such as now has attracted high research interest. Although the academic view on
      this question appears to slightly lean towards the positive effect, no consensus has yet been

      * All opinions expressed in this paper represent the author’s personal views and thus should not be interpreted as Korea Capital
         Market Institute’s official position.
      * Ph.D., Research Fellow, Fund & Pension Department, Tel: 82-2-3771-0645, E-mail: hpark@kcmi.re.kr
      1) J .P. Morgan 2020, Why COVID-19 Could Prove to Be a Major Turning Point for ESG Investing
      2) M
          orningstar 2020, Global Sustainable Fund Flows Report




  1   March 09, 2021

## Page 2

OPINION                                                                       Capital Market Focus



   reached on this matter with many ongoing discussions. Among others, the proponents for ESG’s
   positive impact on financial performance argue that firms with excellent ESG performance have
   a positive corporate image and a high level of confidence at normal times, which could likely
   lead to less consumer exits and higher resilience when hit by a crisis.3) Others also point out that
   those firms’ stable relationship with shareholders, investors, management and staff, suppliers,
   and the local community help them perform stably in a highly volatile market condition. On the
   other hand, those against the positive impact insist that ESG activities are irrelevant to profit-
   seeking, only to incur unnecessary costs to bring down firm value.4) Also mentioned is that the
   nature of ESG information full of unstructured data lowers the reliability of ESG ratings, which
   makes it almost impossible to figure out how ESG is related to financial performance.5)
       Based on those discussions, this article employs domestic data to explore how individual
   firms’ ES performance impacts their stock returns during the pandemic-triggered stock market
   plunge between February 24 and March 18, 2021. By revealing the market’s expectations for
   ESG that is recently gaining ground, this is expected to offer ample implications.


       Covid-19 and ESG stock returns
       Table 1 illustrates stock returns of 867 KOSPI- and KOSDAQ-listed firms with an ES score
   during the analysis period. The analyzed firms were divided into four groups according to their
   ES score. The ES score here uses the average of standardized scores of ES ratings evaluated by
   Korea Corporate Governance Service as of 2019.
       First of all, stock returns during the analysis period confirms that firms with higher ES
   performance show higher returns. A comparative look at the upper and lower 25% groups
   shows even more stark difference: The return of group 4 was 4.7 percentage-point higher than
   that of group 1 during the period. The result remains also consistent for CAPM-adjusted returns
   as firms with superb social and environmental outcomes saw a smaller decline in returns, except
   for group 3 whose return was relatively lower. Another exception was found in group 4 whose
   CAPM-adjusted return was significantly lower by 3.7 percentage-point than that of group 1.6)

   3) F lammer, 2015, Does corporate social responsibility lead to superior financial performance? A regression discontinuity approach;
      Lin et al. 2017, Social capital, trust, and firm performance: The value of corporate social responsibility during the financial crisis.
   4) F riedman 1970, The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits
   5) Berg et al. 2019, Aggregate confusion: The divergence of ESG ratings; Dimson et al. 2020, Divergent ESG ratings
   6) A
       lthough not presented in this article, a regression analysis taking into account firm fixed effects and other controllable variables
      that could affect stock returns reveals a similar result as seen here.



                                                                                                                                                2

## Page 3

OPINION                                                                       Capital Market Focus



                                           Table 1. Stock returns by ES performance

                                                                                                                    Difference
                                               Group 1         Group 2         Group 3         Group 4
                                                                                                                (=Group 4- Group 1)
          Holding period returns (%)             -26.2           -26.1           -26.0           -21.5                 4.7***
          CAPM-adjusted returns (%)               -5.1            -3.7             -6.3            -1.5                3.7**
                No. of samples                    240             197              219             211
      Note:Group 1 to 4 are divided depending on each stock’s ES ratings with group 1 being the lowest and 4 being the highest. Holding
             period returns mean a return during the pandemic-triggered stock market plunge between February 24 and March 18, 2020,
             while CAPM-adjusted returns refer to an excess return taking into account beta. The asterisk mark (*, ** , and ***) indicates
             the statistical significance level of 10%, 5%, and 1%, respectively.



          Figure 1 provides a comparative look at cumulative returns of group 1 and 4 for an extended
      period between January 2 and May 29, 2020. The result confirms a deepened gap between
      returns across the levels of ES performance in the Covid-19 period. It is found that stocks in
      group 4 had a milder decline during abrupt stock market plunges (February 24 to March 18,
      2020), and a faster rebound during the market recovery from March 19, compared to stocks in
      group 1. In other words, stocks with superior ES performance show relatively higher resilience.

                                       Figure 1. Cumulative returns by ES performance

                           Cumulative returns                                 Cumulative excess returns against KOSPI




             Note: The left chart shows the average of cumulative returns on group 1 and group 4 stocks after January 1, 2020. The
                    right chart means the average of cumulative excess returns against KOSPI, with the shaded part indicating the 90%
                    confidence interval.7)




      7) F or convenience, this article uses simple mean, but portfolio returns (weighted average) are more appropriate for the sake of
         comparability. The result remains similar when using the weighted average with a narrower confidence interval.




  3   March 09, 2021

## Page 4

OPINION                                                                     Capital Market Focus



      Conclusion
      ESG has long been part of the core global agenda, and the Covid-19 pandemic is serving
   as a catalyst accelerating this trend. As the idea of a novel virus such as Covid-19 being deeply
   rooted from global warming and environmental destruction is gaining more ground, there
   has been a strengthening of global initiatives for addressing environmental issues. This is also
   leading more and more firms to show keen interest in how to maintain their relationship
   with their staff and the local community despite contracted business activities and business
   deterioration.8) ESG—once treated as part of public relations effort or a mere formality for
   annual report coverage—now means much more than philanthropy, evolving into a major
   standard for firm evaluation.9) Against that backdrop, this article analyzed the relationship
   between environmental, social outcomes and stock returns before and after the financial
   market went through the Covid-19 crisis last year. According to the results, firms with better
   social and environmental outcomes had a significantly lower decline in their stock prices. In
   particular, firms with excellent environmental and social outcomes showed high resilience
   during the first quarter of 2020 when volatility went quite high. Because there is no clear
   academic consensus on whether ESG actually contributes to financial performance or not, it is
   hard to conclude that relationship assertively. What’s worth noting, though, is an increase in
   the number of research results showing that firms with higher ESG performance show stable
   returns during volatile periods. This is calling for domestic investors to take into account ESG
   factors for the sake of risk management.10)




    8) Morgan Stanley, 2020, Coronavirus and ESG: Emphasize the Social
    9) O
        f course, there are many other paths via which ESG affects firm value. Although not discussed fully in this article, there are a
       great number of possibilities, for example, enhancing access to resource via a favorable relationship with the local community
       and the government, expanding business opportunities based on customer confidence, cutting manufacturing costs by reduc-
       ing energy consumption, improving labor productivity via staff encouragement, recruiting talents with a positive corporate
       image and reputation, stabilizing the business environment by minimizing regulatory violations and lawsuits, and generating
       profits by allocating resources to sustainable projects.
   10) MSCI, 2020, MSCI ESG Indexes during the coronavirus crisis; S&P 2020, ESG funds outperform S&P 500 amid COVID-19, helped
       by tech stock boom; HSBC, 2020 ESG stocks did best in COVID-19 slump




                                                                                                                                            4

