---
title: "Structural Shifts in the Credit Bond Market in Response to Market Changes"
document_role: "발간물 글"
language: "en"
published: "2024-06-25"
authors:
  - "Kim, Pil-Kyu"
description: "The credit bond market in Korea has been recently undergoing structural changes, driven by various factors such as rising interest rates, supply-demand imbalances, and heightened credit risk."
canonical_url: "https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pub_detail_view?syear=2024&zcd=002001017&zno=1793&cno=6360"
publication: "OPINION(June 25, 2024)"
---

# Structural Shifts in the Credit Bond Market in Response to Market Changes

[뷰어](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/flexer/view?fid=27035&fgu=002001&fty=004003)
[원글](https://www.kcmi.re.kr/en/publications/pub_detail_view?syear=2024&zcd=002001017&zno=1793&cno=6360)
## Page 1

KOREA CAPITAL MARKET INSTITUTE                                                                        Capital Market Focus




    OPINION                      Structural Shifts in the Credit Bond
      Kim, Pil-Kyu               Market in Response to Market Changes

          The credit bond market in Korea has been recently undergoing structural changes,
      driven by various factors such as rising interest rates, supply-demand imbalances,
      and heightened credit risk. The increased volatility in interest rates has led to a sharp
      decline in average maturities of domestic credit bonds, prompting a surge in financing
      cost ratios. As evolving market conditions have increased refinancing instability, the
      issuance of floating rate notes (FRNs) has expanded during certain periods. In addition,
      credit bonds have been utilized not only for their primary purpose of capital raising but
      also for supplementing equity capital.

          These structural changes in the bond market can be attributed to the financing
      strategies employed by credit bond issuers as well as changing market conditions.
      Despite various attempts to improve financing efficiency, the outlook for market
      conditions remains unfavorable. Persistent inflationary pressures defy market
      expectations, casting uncertainty over the timing of policy rate cuts. Even if interest
      rates drop, a return to the low interest rate environment is unlikely. Concerns
      about project financing (PF) defaults have barely abated, and some industries have
      experienced credit rating downgrades. Furthermore, the rise in financing cost ratios
      stemming from higher interest rates is likely to further strain corporate financial health.

          To maintain the health of the credit bond market amidst these evolving conditions, it
      is crucial for credit bond issuers to enhance profitability, strengthen risk management,
      and improve financial stability. On top of that, policy support is needed to enhance
      stability in the credit bond market. Alongside macro-prudential policies, a robust
      financial support system should be established to swiftly address any market disruption
      event.




* All opinions expressed in this paper represent the author’s personal views and thus should not be interpreted as Korea Capital
   Market Institute’s official position.
* Ph.D., Senior Research Fellow, Capital Markets Department, Tel: 82-2-3771-0631, E-mail: pkkim@kcmi.re.kr




1

## Page 2

June 25, 2024




    Since the major crash in the credit bond1) market caused by the Legoland crisis in October
2022, the environment surrounding the market has been rapidly evolving due to a supply-
demand imbalance resulting from large-scale issuance of Korea Electric Power Corporation
(KEPCO) bonds, inflation-induced high interest rates, and increased credit risk in certain
industries stemming from concerns over project financing (PF) defaults.
    Recent changes in the financial market have affected the cost of financing and the feasibility
of refinancing for credit bond issuers. In response, these issuers are making various efforts to
improve financing efficiency by adjusting maturities and adopting various bond structures.
    Against this backdrop, this article aims to understand how changing market conditions, such
as rising interest rates, influence the credit bond market. To this end, it analyzes the distribution
of credit ratings, the financing cost ratio,2) maturity structures, and characteristics of domestic
credit bonds. It also examines the major risk factors and potential countermeasures for the
future credit bond market.


    Issuance of credit bonds
    Credit bonds are a primary financing tool employed by public enterprises, financial
institutions, and non-financial companies. Despite the increasing financing costs resulting
from global rate hikes, the issuance of credit bonds in Korea has been steadily rising. Credit
bond issuance grew from KRW 234.4 trillion in 2015 to KRW 374.5 trillion in 2020, and saw
a significant year-on-year increase to KRW 460 trillion in 2023. As this upward trend has
continued well into the current year, the issuance volume reached KRW 188.1 trillion as of the
end of May 2024, showing a slight year-on-year increase.
    The growth in credit bond issuance has been mainly led by financial bonds. Annual issuance
of financial bonds consistently increased from KRW 142.3 trillion in 2015 to 303.2 trillion
in 2023, and this trend is continuing into 2024. On the other hand, the issuance of special
bonds has shown variability year by year. In 2022 and 2023, there was a significant increase in
special bond issuance, particularly driven by the expansion of KEPCO bond issuance. However,
this year, the issuance of KEPCO bonds has almost ceased, resulting in a sharp decline in the
issuance volume of special bonds compared to the same period last year. Corporate bonds


1) In this article, credit bonds refer to bonds with inherent credit risk, including special bonds, financial bonds, and corporate bonds.
2) T he yield of bonds issued is defined as the financial cost ratio.



                                                                                                                                        2

## Page 3

Capital Market Focus




have also seen a steady rise in issuance volume, fueled by increased financing activities from
companies with high credit ratings.

                                         Figure 1. Credit bond issuance
                        <By year>                                         <Recent trends>




      Note: This is based on issuance data, excluding MBS and ABS.
      Source: Yonhap Infomax




    The majority of publicly offered unsecured credit bonds in Korea are rated A or higher,
reflecting conservative investment criteria adopted by investors who consider these
bonds eligible investments. The proportion of credit bonds by credit rating is influenced by
macroeconomic factors and the supply-demand dynamics in the credit bond market. In 2022,
the proportion of AAA-rated bonds surged due to heightened investor sensitivity to credit
risk following the Legoland crisis, making it difficult for the market to absorb even AA-rated
bonds. More recently, there has been a growing demand for A-rated bonds as investors seek to
improve profitability.
    The structure of the Korean credit bond market, which predominantly favors blue-chip
bonds, imposes constraints on fundraising activities of companies and financial institutions
seeking to issue bonds. Companies with lower credit ratings often resort to alternative
fundraising methods such as borrowing from financial institutions, private placements, or
issuing equity-linked bonds, rather than publicly issuing unsecured bonds.




3

## Page 4

June 25, 2024




                  Figure 2. Proportion of credit bonds by credit rating in Korea




                       Source: Yonhap Infomax, author’s calculation




   Maturity structure of credit bonds
   Bonds serve as a long-term financing tool for companies and financial institutions.
Historically, domestic credit bonds typically had a maturity of around three years, which limited
their role as a long-term financing source. However, with the extension of maturities for special
bonds and the increase in the issuance of capital securities, the usefulness of credit bonds as a
long-term financing tool has improved. Nonetheless, not all issuers are utilizing credit bonds for
long-term financing; only companies and financial institutions with high credit ratings have the
capacity to issue long-term credit bonds.
   An analysis of the maturity structure of credit bonds in Korea reveals a decreasing trend in
average maturities in recent years. The average maturity of all credit bonds declined from 4.34
years in 2015 to 3.86 years in 2020, and as of May 2024, the average maturity of credit bonds
stood at 2.72 years. This recent shortening in average maturities can be attributed to increased
issuance of short-term credit bonds amid rising interest rates. Notably, strategies have been
adopted to issue short-term bonds with market expectations for a decrease in interest rates in
2024, while long-term bonds are planned when interest rates fall.
   By credit bond type, special bonds typically exhibit a longer average maturity, whereas
financial bonds tend to have a shorter average maturity. This variation in average maturities
across institutions reflects differing preferences for financing periods. Public corporations
often seek long-term financing, resulting in extended average maturities. In contrast, financial



                                                                                                 4

## Page 5

Capital Market Focus




institutions issue publicly-offered unsecured bonds with shorter maturities to adapt flexibly
to market conditions, while opting for contingent capital securities for long-term financing
purposes.
    By credit rating, the proportion of long-term credit bonds tends to increase with higher credit
ratings. Issuers with high credit ratings have the capacity to absorb long-term credit bonds,
thus favoring the issuance of long-term credit bonds in the low interest rate environment. As
a result, the average maturity stood at more than four years until 2021. However, recent rate
hikes have prompted even high-credit-rated financial institutions to increasingly issue short-
term bonds in anticipation of future rate cuts, leading to shorter average maturities.

                              Figure 3. Average maturity of credit bonds in Korea
                   <By credit bond type>                               <By credit rating>




        Note: 1) Based on publicly-offered unsecured bonds
              2) Value-weighted average maturities
        Source: Yonhap Infomax, author’s calculation




    Financing cost ratios of credit bonds
    In response to global inflationary pressures following the Covid-19 pandemic, central banks
worldwide raised policy rates, leading to a surge in most real interest rates by the end of 2022.
In 2023, interest rates temporarily declined as market sentiment supported expectations for
policy rate cuts. However, persistently high levels of inflation continue to push back rate cuts.
Even if rates do fall, it is unlikely that interest rates will return to the low levels observed in the
past.
    The rise in real interest rates has had a direct impact on the increase in financing cost ratios



5

## Page 6

June 25, 2024




of publicly-offered unsecured credit bonds. The average financing cost ratio for such bonds
climbed from 1.89% in 2021 to 4.09% in 2022. Despite a slight decline in bond yields in 2023,
the financing cost ratio for publicly-offered unsecured credit bonds rose year-on-year to 4.45%.
In 2024, expectations for rate cuts in the second half of the year have led to a decrease in bond
issuance rates, with the average financing cost ratio for credit bonds issued through the end of
May reaching 4.41%, down from 4.89% of the previous year.
   By credit bond type, the financing cost ratios for special bonds declined year-on-year in
2023, while those for financial and corporate bonds posted a year-on-year increase. The recent
divergence in average financing cost ratios from bond yield fluctuations can be attributed to the
credit quality and issuer composition of credit bonds. Specifically, the weight of relatively lower-
rated bonds increased in financial and corporate bonds as investors pursued higher returns and
adjusted risk preferences, contributing significantly to the year-on-year rise in average financing
cost ratios.
   In 2023, the financing cost ratios for AAA- and AA-rated bonds remained similar to the
levels of the previous year, whereas the ratios for bonds rated A or lower experienced a year-
on-year surge. This result occurred because, during the credit crunch following the Legoland
crisis, issuers of A-rated and lower bonds issued them at relatively high yields, especially for
refinancing purposes. Meanwhile, financing cost ratios across all ratings have been declining in
2024, and the interest rate difference between credit ratings has also been narrowing.

                                Figure 4. Financing cost ratios of credit bonds
                 <By credit bond type>                                             <By credit rating>




     Note: 1) Based on publicly-offered unsecured credit bonds
           2) Credit spreads are based on Korea Treasury Bonds with the same maturity.
     Source: Yonhap Infomax, author’s calculation




                                                                                                                   6

## Page 7

Capital Market Focus




    Issuing different types of credit bonds
    To adapt to evolving market conditions, credit bond issuers are diversifying their bond
issuance strategies. With rising interest rates and heightened supply-demand imbalances
of credit bonds, some companies and financial institutions have temporarily expanded the
issuance of Floating Rate Notes (FRNs) to meet investor demand. An analysis of this trend by
period indicates a significant surge in the proportion of FRNs issued in 2022 and 2023, when
KEPCO’s expansion of bond issuance intensified the supply-demand instability. The increase
in FRN issuance during this period reflects the challenges faced by these issuers in absorbing
coupon bonds amidst the supply-demand instability. Consequently, companies and financial
institutions have scaled up their FRN issuance to better cater to investor demand.
    On top of that, there has been a shift in the reference yield structure for FRNs. The majority
of newly issued FRNs utilize Constant Maturity Swap (CMS) rates, instead of the conventional
91-day CD rate, as their reference yield. This shift is driven by the CMS rate’s ability to quickly
reflect market interest rates compared to the CD rate.

                       Figure 5. Proportion of FRN issuance in credit bonds




                       Source: Yonhap Infomax, author’s calculation




    In general, credit bonds serve as a long-term, stable source of financing for companies and
financial institutions. Apart from their primary function in capital raising, they are also used to
bolster supplementary capital. Issuers of credit bonds typically issue long-term subordinated
bonds and Hybrid Tier 1 instruments to raise long-term funds and increase their equity ratios.
    Capital securities are primarily issued by financial institutions such as banks, bank holding



7

## Page 8

June 25, 2024




companies, insurance companies, securities firms, and credit finance companies. Recently, non-
financial companies also tend to issue capital securities to increase their equity capital. In 2023,
non-financial companies issued KRW 1.4 trillion worth of capital securities, and as of 2024,
KRW 1.4 trillion worth of capital securities have been issued.
   Capital securities offer the benefit of improving the capital structure and facilitating
relatively long-term financing, despite higher financing costs stemming from their subordinated
structure. Therefore, they are widely utilized by companies and financial institutions as a means
to enhance corporate financial structures.


   Looking ahead
   As discussed above, the credit bond market in Korea is experiencing substantial changes
in maturity structures, financing cost ratios, and bond structures as the market environment
is evolving. In response to rate hikes and a shift in credit supply-demand conditions, domestic
credit bond issuers have increased the issuance of short-term bonds, and are endeavoring to
improve financing efficiency by diversifying bond structures. Despite these efforts, the upward
trend in interest rates driven by inflationary pressures is driving up financing cost ratios for
credit bonds, thereby posing challenges for credit bond issuers in the market.
   Looking ahead, the conditions surrounding the credit bond market remain challenging.
Contrary to market expectations, inflationary pressures are mounting, raising uncertainty about
the timing of policy rate cuts. Even if a cycle of rate cuts begins, a return to the previous low
interest rate environment is unlikely. The rise in financing cost ratios, led by rising interest rates,
poses a potential threat to corporate financial health. In addition, there is a high probability of
prolonged PF distress and a slowdown in the construction sector, and some industries may face
credit rating downgrades due to sluggish operating performance. Furthermore, the volume of
credit bonds maturing this year is expected to increase year-on-year, weighing down on supply
and demand conditions.
   In the face of these market changes, credit bond issuers should strive to improve profitability,
strengthen risk management, and enhance financial stability. They also need to increase the
efficiency of financing structures that align with evolving financing conditions. In this respect,
it is crucial to establish an efficient financing strategy tailored to specific characteristics of




                                                                                                     8

## Page 9

Capital Market Focus




credit bond issuers, such as business size, creditworthiness, existing funding structures, and
refinancing capacity.
    Policy efforts are also needed to enhance the stability of the credit bond market. Worsening
funding conditions in the market have been primarily driven by external factors rather than
the financing structure of issuers. In particular, an external shock, such as the Legoland crisis,
drives up financing costs and exacerbates refinancing risks for issuers. Hence, it is necessary
to proactively implement policies to mitigate factors that lead to capital market instability. A
financial support system should be designed to swiftly address any potential market disruption
event. Additionally, policy efforts are needed to enhance the stability of the credit bond market.
Specifically, it is crucial to implement policies to reduce inflationary pressures and stabilize
interest rates. Lower interest rates can contribute to reducing refinancing costs and burdens for
credit bond issuers and ultimately enhance their financial stability.




9

